The Proxxon vs Dremel debate isn’t likely to end soon as each one has its own followers. So which one really is good for you? Well, that is what this comparison review is for.
Here I’ll take a look at the Proxxon 28512, 38472 and the 3848 and who they compare to the Dremel 4000 and the 4200. The Proxxon line claims it is an alternative to users in need of a power tool, but does the company live up to that claim?
To find out if this is true, I did a detailed review of each product, the speed, ease of use and what its applications are. The following reveals my findings about these rotary tools.
Table of Contents
- 1 Proxxon vs Dremel Rotary Tool Comparison Table
- 2 Proxxon vs Dremel Rotary Tool Reviews
- 2.1 #1: Proxxon 28512 12-Volt Micromot 50 EF Rotary Tool
- 2.2 #2: Proxxon 38472 FBS 115/E Precision Rotary Tool
- 2.3 #3: Proxxon 38481 Professional Rotary Tool IBS/E
- 2.4 #4: Dremel 4000-2/30 120-Volt Variable Speed Rotary Tool Kit
- 2.5 #5: Dremel 4200-4/36 High Performance Rotary Tool Kit
- 2.6 #6: Dremel 4300-9/64 High Performance Rotary Tool Kit with Universal 3-Jaw Chuck, 9 Attachments and 64 Accessories
- 3 Feature Comparison Proxxon vs Dremel
- 4 Why Get The Dremel Over The Proxxon Tools?
- 5 Why Not Get The Dremel Over The Proxxon Tools?
- 6 Final Verdict
Proxxon vs Dremel Rotary Tool Comparison Table
Before we take a look at the detailed reviews, this table will give you a snapshot of what each product is about and what they offer the buyer.
|Product||Proxxon 28512||Proxxon 38472||Proxxon 38481||Dremel 4000-2/30||Dremel 4200-4/36||Dremel 4200-4/36|
|Specialty||Cutting, grinding, sharpening, polishing, sanding, carving, engraving, cleaning||Cutting, grinding, sharpening, polishing, sanding, carving, engraving, cleaning||Cutting, grinding, sharpening, polishing, sanding, carving, engraving, cleaning||Cutting, grinding, sharpening, polishing, sanding, carving, engraving, cleaning||Cutting, grinding, sharpening, polishing, sanding, carving, engraving, cleaning||Cutting, grinding, sharpening, polishing, sanding, carving, engraving, cleaning|
|Number of Accessories||N/A||43 accessories||34 cutters and bits with 6 collets||30 accessories and 2 attachments||36 accessories and 4 attachments||64 accessories and 9 attachments|
|Weight||1.5 lbs||2.08 lbs||1.5 pounds||4.4 pounds||1.18 pounds||1.18 pounds|
|Dimensions||1.5 x 11.4 x 6.5 inches||5.3 x 2.5 x 10.4 inches||13 x 8.1 x 4.4 inches||13.9 x 9.4 x 4 inches||15.2 x 10.2 x 3.8 inches||9 x 2 x 2 inches|
|Price||Check Price on Amazon||Check Price on Amazon||Check Price on Amazon||Check Price on Amazon||Check Price on Amazon||Check Price on Amazon|
Proxxon vs Dremel Rotary Tool Reviews
Proxxon and Dremel manufacture a lot of products, but I picked these because they are the most popular and widely used. Let’s take a look at each one.
#1: Proxxon 28512 12-Volt Micromot 50 EF Rotary Tool
The 28512 does not get mentioned a lot in the Proxxon vs Dremel 4000 debate, but it’s one of the more versatile tools Dremel has.
This is a compact rotary tool for those who don’t need a fancy utility. At just 1 1/2 lbs and 11.5 inches wide, the 28512 is suitable for various light to medium tasks and projects.
Its DC motor is powerful but quiet, ideal for long term use. Its chuck is well-designed and used properly should last a long time.
With its keyless chuck and variable speed, the 28512 can handle the tasks you throw at it. Another advantage is it works with different shafts ranging from 1/32” to 1/8”.
The Proxxon 28512 is especially good when it’s used with different types of HS drill bits. No matter what size you’re working it’s easy because the tool is light and easy to use.
The 28512 is made of polyamide that’s been fortified with fiber. The handle is well balanced, soft and comfortable to hold.
The 28512 doesn’t have an on/off switch. Instead you just plug it into the Proxxon supply and turn it on and off from there.
Performance wise the 28512 delivers. The speed control functions as advertised. The other nice thing about this is it doesn’t overheat the way some high end rotary tools do.
#2: Proxxon 38472 FBS 115/E Precision Rotary Tool
A lot of the Proxxon vs Dremel rotary tools debate focus on specific models like the 38472. It is a versatile rotary tool that is designed for cutting, carving, engraving, de-rusting and deburring.
The 38472 can also be used for polishing, grinding, milling and drilling, underscoring its efficiency. This rotary tool is equipped with an advanced motor for handling different tasks.
The 38472 doesn’t require you to change brushes, plus it has a comprehensive electronic speed control.
The electronic controls ensure the tool delivers consistent performance. This feature also ensures you get a sufficient amount of torque when you use it.
The 38472 Proxxon produces torque even when you’re running it at low speed, making it ideal for polishing and brushing sensitive objects.
The motor is also finely balanced and reduces the possibility of overheating. The 38472 is also free of vibrations so you can it in comfort.
The 38472 also sports an ergonomic design so your hand doesn’t get tired while using it. Need to change the bit? Just use the button lock spindle to do it, a more convenient method compared to those of other rotary tools.
Apart from the spindle lock, the ball bearing also makes the unit easier to work with. Lastly it has a keyless chuck so you can use it with 1/64” to 1/8” shanks.
#3: Proxxon 38481 Professional Rotary Tool IBS/E
The 38481 tips the scale at just 1.3 lbs and is only 9 inches long. Yet it packs 1/8 horsepower to carry out various tasks.
The 38481 goes from 5,000 to 20,000 RPM which means it is more than capable of satisfying your requirements. These specs are complemented by its powerful motor that can handle a lot of different projects.
The powerful specs makes the 38481 a good option for engraving, grinding, cutting, cleaning and polishing. You also get 34 cutters and bits designed for industrial use.
For a lot of people the highlight here is the 6 collets, 1/8, 7/64, 3/3-2, 5/64, 1/16 and 1/32 inches. Performance wise the 38481 is very smooth and the variable speed allows you to use it for professional and hobby projects.
You can run the 38481 at high torque without feeling vibrations or a performance dip. The This rotary tool is also quiet and light, so even at a high torque you’ll get optimum results.
A storage case is provided where you can store the 34 accessory pieces. Half a dozen triple slit collets are included. The RPM and the 1/8 HP motor also deliver in the performance department.
#4: Dremel 4000-2/30 120-Volt Variable Speed Rotary Tool Kit
The 4000 2/30 is a powerful rotary tool with an RPM of 5,000 to 35,000. It also has a dial so you can fine tune the speed to match the need of your project.
A carry case is provided where you can store the Dremel 4000 and the 30 accessories. A coupe of Dremel attachments are bundled, giving you more ways to cut, polish, grind and otherwise work on your project.
The Dremel 4000 is particularly good at engraving and carving. By using its cutter you’ll be able to carve on wood, metal, plastic and other materials. You can also use this tool to create tapered openings on materials.
The other accessories on the 4000 lets you slot, groove, hollow and shape materials in different ways. Because it’s Dremel you’re assured it’s high quality and compatible with all Dremel accessories.
The variable speed gives you better control of the process no matter what material you’re working on. It also has the EZ Twist nose cap so you can replace accessories with ease. It also has an electronic feedback and 1.6 amp for consistent performance.
#5: Dremel 4200-4/36 High Performance Rotary Tool Kit
If we base the Proxxon vs Dremel 4200 comparison on power alone, the 4200 wins. For starters, the unit has a 5,000 to 35,000 RPM, thus giving you have full control over the project you’re working on.
The Dremel 4200 comes with 36 accessories and 4 attachments. Together these features allow you to work on different types of projects without straining the tool.
The Dremel 4200 design is also superior to that of other rotary tools. It has a cooler that allows it to produce up to 20% better airflow compared to other rotary tools. This is a crucial feature to ensure the system does not overheat.
The Dremel 4200 also has an EZ Change System so you don’t need to use a collet lock or wrench to replace any of the accessories.
The 4200 comes with a garden tool sharpener and lawn mower attachment to manage your garden. You also get the A550 shield rotary attachment, 565 multipurpose cutting kit and an A576 grinding/sanding guide.
The accessories include a 191 1/8″ high speed cutter and a 07 1/8″ engraving HS cutter for all types of cutting tasks.
For sharpening and grinding, there is a 932 3/8″ aluminum oxide, a 84922 3/16″ silicon carbide and another 8193 5/8″ aluminum oxide accessory.
#6: Dremel 4300-9/64 High Performance Rotary Tool Kit with Universal 3-Jaw Chuck, 9 Attachments and 64 Accessories
When it comes to the Dremel 4300 vs Proxxon rotary tool question, the 4300 has an edge given its many features. It has 64 accessories and multiple attachments so you can work on assorted projects.
One of the more contested areas in the Dremel vs Proxxon debate is the accessory and attachment set. It’s good to know the Dremel 4300 does not disappoint.
Its attachments include a Pivot Light to make your work easier. You also get a 679 garden tool sharpener and guides for cutting, grinding and sanding.
You also get a right angle attachment and straight edge guide, both of whose functions are self explanatory. A 225 flex shaft is included as well as an A550 shield and a cutter for circles.
A mandrel is included as well as drum sanding band. Accessories for polishing, cleaning, sharpening, grinding, cutting, engraving and carving are also included.
The Dremel 4300 lets you change accessories via its 3 jaw chuck. This means you no longer need to use a collet or tool to replace them.
The 4300 delivers a powerful performance thanks to its motor. Its electronic feedback circuitry and variable speed gives you even more control.
The 4300 also scores points for its ergonomic design, ensuring you’ll be comfortable while using it. And with its 360 degree Grip Zone you’ll be at ease no matter how you hold it.
Feature Comparison Proxxon vs Dremel
- Proxxon and Dremel rotary tools are corded and electrically powered.
- In terms of amp, Dremel rotary tools are more powerful. Voltage is similar however.
- Both Proxxon and Dremel tools have variable speed built in.
- Proxxon rotary tools are lighter but only by a few grams.
- Cord length varies per model. The Proxxon 38481 for instance, has a 7.5 feet cord compared to 6 feet for the Dremel 4000.
- Most Proxxon rotary tools are compatible with Dremel bits.
- The Dremel 4000 rotary tools use the EZ Twist System for changing accessories. Some Dremel rotary tools use a quick collet lock with the EZ Twist for accessory switching.
- Proxxon tools use a lock button to change accessories.
- Most Dremel and Proxxon have separate on/off switches, ball bearing construction and speed dial.
- Some Proxxon rotary tools like the 38481 has Active Control Circuitry and carry case provided.
- The Dremel 4000 have motor brushes which you can replace.
- The built in features make the Proxxon and Dremel rotary tools suitable for difference tasks.
- The Dremel 4000 series is a do it all rotary tool for home and on site use. It is generally more powerful and offers more options for speeds.
- The Proxxon rotary tools however, are more suitable for intricate, detailed work.
- The Dremel rotary tools are ergonomic, well balanced and built for long term use.
- The Proxxon rotary tools are notable for being quieter than other models.
- Both the Dremel and Proxxon rotary tools can cut through different materials.
- Both brands offer tools that work with different types of accessories.
- Both Dremel and Proxxon are built with versatility in mind, though the Dremel is more powerful.
- Both brands offer reliable customer support.
- All the rotary tools here have ergonomic handles.
Why Get The Dremel Over The Proxxon Tools?
- The Dremel has a greater RPM speed compared to the Proxxon.
- Its amperage is higher than a Proxxon rotary tool.
- There are more kits to choose from.
- The Dremel is a better all around rotary tool compared to the Proxxon.
- The Dremel 4000 have speed circuitry control to counter overload.
- You’re assured it is compatible with all Dremel attachments and accessories.
- Dremel rotary tools have RPM greater than 20,000 RPM.
- You get more flexibility, versatility and strength compared to the Proxxon.
- The Dremel rotary tools last longer even if used heavily.
Why Not Get The Dremel Over The Proxxon Tools?
- Proxxon rotary tools operate quietly even when at maximum speed.
- Proxxon rotary tools are better balanced.
- Accessories and bits are of good quality.
- Better than Dremel when it comes to precision work.
- The 38481 doesn’t overheat as quickly as other rotary tools.
- The Proxxon rotary tools are legitimate alternatives to Dremel.
- The Proxxon 381481 have six collets of varying sizes
- Dremel rotary tools are noisier.
- Dremel tools need a flex shaft for delicate carving. You can buy these easily enough but that is an added expense whereas with Proxxon it’s free.
- You don’t need the kind of power that a typical Dremel rotary tool does.
So there you have it, our detailed review of the top Dremel and Proxxon rotary tools. And what is obvious here is there is no best Proxxon or best Dremel rotary tool. Instead the best tool depends on what you need. Generally, Dremel rotary tools are more powerful, suitable for home and onsite use.
Proxxon tools on the other hand, are being marketed as the alternative. They’re not as powerful but can meet the needs of homeowners and DIY buffs. For professionals, you may want to check out the Dremel 4000 instead. So to answer the Proxxon vs Dremel question, it really comes down to what you need.